Waterstone Financial (WSBF) Q3 2026 earnings review

Waterstone's problem loans rise, and its mortgage unit loses money

Waterstone Financial, a Milwaukee-area bank with a national home-loan business, earned more from lending but lost money on mortgages. Its net interest income, what it earns on loans minus what it pays for funds, rose 11% as deposits cost less. The mortgage unit sold loans at thinner margins after rates jumped. Chief executive William Bruss called it "another strong quarter", yet profit per share fell to $0.36.

At a glance
Revenue (lending income plus fees)$35.7M −3.6% from a year ago
Profit per share$0.36 −20% from a year ago
Lending margin (net interest margin)3.06% 2.76% a year ago
OutlookNone given

⚖️ Verdict: 🔴 Bearish

The story got worse, mainly because loans that stopped paying interest nearly doubled since December. Waterstone tied most of the rise to one large borrower. The good news: the bank's lending margin widened again, as in every quarter for two years.

The question now is whether that borrower stays a single problem or becomes the first of several. If it stays alone, the wider lending margin keeps lifting income; if others follow, new reserves will absorb the gain. The year-end count of loans that stopped paying will settle it.

🐂 Bull Case

🟢🟢 MARGIN

Cheaper Deposits Widen the Bank's Lending Margin

Net interest margin is what Waterstone earns on loans and bonds minus what it pays for funds, as a share of earning assets. Chief executive William Bruss credited a lower "average cost of funds" for the bank's record lending income. He tied that to "continued growth in average transaction deposits", meaning everyday checking and money market balances.

The margin reached 3.06%, against 2.76% a year ago. It has widened in each of the last eight quarters. Retail certificates of deposit, which lock savers' money for a fixed term, cost 3.56%, down from 3.92%.

This matters because interest expense fell by almost 5 percentage points as a share of interest income, to 45%. About $899 million of certificates mature within a year, so the bank can reset rates on most deposits within months. But Waterstone paid more on money market accounts, 2.13% against 2.04%, to attract new accounts, the filing said.

What to watch: the net interest margin in the fourth-quarter results. A further rise would show cheaper certificates still outweigh the costlier savings accounts.

🟢 GROWTH

Loan Commitments Rose More Than Fivefold This Year

Besides selling home loans, Waterstone keeps loans on its own books, mostly on apartment and commercial buildings near Milwaukee. It has made $252 million of such loans so far this year, up 39% from a year earlier. The bigger change is in loans it has promised but not yet paid out. Those commitments reached $70.5 million in September, against $12.7 million at the end of last year.

This matters because new loans keep lending income growing once deposit costs stop falling. The growth has a cost: Waterstone set aside $571,000 for commitments not yet drawn, mostly construction and commercial property loans.

What to watch: average loans held for investment in the fourth quarter. A figure above this quarter's $1.70 billion would show the commitments turning into earning loans.

🐻 Bear Case

🔴🔴 MARGIN contradicts narrative

The Mortgage Unit Fell Back Into a Loss

Waterstone Mortgage makes home loans in 48 states and sells them to investors. Chief executive William Bruss said sales margins "continue to remain under pressure", and that a "significant jump in mortgage rates" held back lending volume.

The unit lost $754,000 before tax, against a $1.3 million profit a year ago. Its gain-on-sale margin, what it earns per dollar of loans it makes, has slipped for four straight quarters. The latest reading is 3.48%, against 3.87% a year ago.

The loss also understates the problem. Inside that figure is a $391,000 gain from selling servicing rights, the right to collect payments on sold loans. Without that gain, the loss would have reached about $1.1 million by our math. Costs also failed to shrink with revenue.

  • Pay and benefits: 79% of the unit's revenue, against 75% a year ago
  • Other costs, including a reserve for sold loans investors may return: 10% of revenue, against 6%

What to watch: the gain-on-sale margin in the fourth-quarter results. A reading below 3.48% would leave the unit losing money even with lower pay.

🔴 MARGIN

Problem Loans Rose Sharply in One Quarter

Nonperforming assets are loans that stopped paying interest plus repossessed property. At Waterstone they reached 0.55% of assets in September, against 0.30% in June. The bank tied the rise to "one significant relationship which was previously identified as substandard", a borrower it already rated as weak.

  • Commercial property loans no longer earning interest: $4.4 million, against $0.1 million in December
  • Provision for credit losses: 1.2% of revenue, against a 0.7% release a year ago

This matters because reserves now cover 155% of loans not earning interest, against 295% a year ago, so new losses hit profit faster. Waterstone has charged off none of them.

What to watch: nonperforming assets in the fourth-quarter results. A figure above 0.55% would mean the trouble reaches beyond one borrower.

🔴 MARGIN

Bank Segment Profit Slipped Despite Record Lending Income

The community bank, Waterstone's 14 branches around Milwaukee, earned record lending income this quarter. Yet its pre-tax profit slipped 2.1% to $8.3 million, because costs and loss provisions grew faster.

Pay and benefits at the segment rose 12% to $5.6 million. The bank cited higher salaries, health insurance and the cost of its employee stock ownership plan. Pay now takes 32.5% of the segment's revenue, against 31.5% a year ago.

This matters because the segment's efficiency ratio, its costs as a share of revenue, rose to 49.6% from 48.9%. So costs, up 9.9%, now grow about as fast as lending income.

What to watch: the community bank's efficiency ratio in the fourth quarter. A reading above 50% would mean costs are absorbing the gains from cheaper deposits.

👓 Other Themes

MACRO

Higher Treasury Rates Cut Book Value

Book value, the shareholders' equity behind each share, fell $0.24 in the quarter to $19.29, chief executive William Bruss said. Rising Treasury rates cut the market value of the bank's bonds, and Waterstone put that effect at about $0.46 a share. Earnings covered part of the hit. The losses stay on paper unless Waterstone sells the bonds, and the filing says it does not intend to.

💲 Other KPIs

Average borrowings (26Q3) $388.7 million
⇘ decelerating

Waterstone keeps swapping borrowed money for deposits. Average borrowings fell 11.9% from a year ago, while average interest-bearing deposits grew 4.5%. Borrowings, mostly Federal Home Loan Bank advances, totaled $391.3 million at quarter end. The shift trims interest expense, because deposits cost less than those advances.

Diluted share count (26Q3) 17.19 million
⇘ decelerating

The diluted share count fell 2.7% from a year ago because of earlier buybacks. But Waterstone bought back no shares this quarter, after about 446,000 in the first half. The board approved a 2.0 million-share program in April, and nearly all of it remains unused. The quarterly dividend held at $0.17.

Tier 1 leverage ratio (26Q3) 16.42%
⇗ accelerating

Tier 1 leverage, core capital as a share of average assets, rose to 16.42% from 15.94% in December. Chief executive William Bruss said the group remains "in a strong capital position". The bank's own ratio, 15.36%, clears the 5% level regulators require for a well-capitalized rating.

❓ Key Questions

Will the large problem loan cost Waterstone money?

One commercial property relationship drove most of the rise in nonperforming assets. Waterstone holds a specific reserve but has charged off nothing. Readers need the collateral value and a timeline for resolving the loan.

Why did buybacks stop this quarter?

Waterstone bought back shares in each of the prior quarters, then none this quarter despite a new program from April. The reason matters, because a shrinking share count has supported profit per share.

How many sold loans could investors send back?

The mortgage unit lifted its reserve for loans investors may return to $1.5 million from $1.0 million at year end. Waterstone has not said how large the risky pool is or what caused the problem.

Can mortgage costs fall as fast as margins?

The unit's costs exceeded its revenue this quarter. Management has not said whether it will trim loan officers or offices if gain-on-sale margins stay near today's level.

Will Waterstone give any outlook for next year?

The company gives no forecast for lending income, margins or mortgage volume. A view on deposit costs would help, since most of its certificates of deposit mature within a year.