StoneX (SNEX) Q4 2026 earnings review
StoneX commercial hedging jumps, but tighter spreads hurt institutional profit
StoneX's corporate hedging and metals desk carried the fourth quarter while its institutional securities and retail currency units fell back. The financial brokerage group grew net operating revenue 12% from a year ago to $655 million, and chief executive Philip Smith said the firm completed its R.J. O'Brien integration on schedule while hitting its cost-savings targets. Pre-tax profit rose 10%, but a higher tax rate and stock issued for the acquisition pushed profit per share down 6% to $0.66.
| Operating revenue ex R.J. O'Brien | +19% from a year ago by our math (total +21%) |
|---|---|
| Net operating revenue | $655.2M +12% from a year ago, -9% from Q3 |
| Profit per share | $0.66 -6% from a year ago (pre-tax profit +10%) |
| R.J. O'Brien integration plan | Achieved completed on schedule with synergy targets met |
⚖️ Verdict: ⚪ Neutral
The standing case is unchanged because surprising strength in corporate commodity hedging offset a sharp drop in institutional and float income. Commercial net operating revenue rose to $334 million even as overall market swings calmed down, pushing back against fears that second-quarter profits were a one-off spike. The bad news: tighter bond and stock spreads cut institutional profit by a quarter, and an $18 million unrealized bond loss dragged net interest on client cash down 16%.
The question now is whether StoneX can grow quarterly profit once the R.J. O'Brien acquisition is fully in the year-ago comparison next quarter. Bulls see 45% underlying growth in client cash balances and $50 million of merger cost savings driving earnings, while skeptics see falling interest rates and tighter trading spreads squeezing margins. First-quarter net interest income and institutional trading rates will settle the debate.
🐂 Bull Case
Commercial Hedging and Precious Metals Carried the Quarter
StoneX's Commercial division helps businesses hedge price risks in raw materials, farm goods and energy. Many feared that calmer markets after the second quarter's geopolitical flare-up would cause corporate hedging and metals trading to dry up.
Instead, Commercial net operating revenue (revenue after direct trading, clearing and interest costs) grew 54% from a year ago to $333.6 million, even beating the third quarter's $326.4 million. Customers nearly doubled their over-the-counter (OTC) derivative contracts, which are custom hedging contracts traded directly rather than on an exchange, while physical precious metals operating revenue jumped by $46.4 million.
- Commercial segment profit: $188.1 million, up 66% from a year ago
- OTC derivative volume: 1.94 million contracts, up 97% from a year ago
- Physical contracts net operating revenue: $100.0 million, up 101% from a year ago
- Commercial bad debts: a $7.3 million net recovery, reversing prior credit charges
This performance matters because Commercial generated more than half of StoneX's total segment profit this quarter. The $7.3 million bad-debt recovery also eased concerns after customer defaults in precious metals hurt the first half of the year.
What to watch: first-quarter physical and OTC revenue when the broker laps a full quarter of its R.J. O'Brien acquisition. Holding Commercial net operating revenue near $300 million would prove that corporate hedging demand does not rely on crisis-level price swings.
Underlying Client Balances Grew 45% as Integration Finished
StoneX bought futures broker R.J. O'Brien (RJO) in July 2025 to build the largest non-bank futures clearing firm. Because last year's fourth quarter already included two months of RJO, headline growth in average listed-derivatives client equity — cash that customers keep on deposit for exchange trading — slowed to 26% from 129% in the third quarter.
Strip out RJO's $6.0 billion contribution this quarter and $5.6 billion a year ago, however, and underlying client equity rose 45% from a year ago to $8.3 billion by our math. Chief executive Philip Smith also confirmed that the company "successfully integrated our largest acquisition to date, on schedule whilst achieving our capital and cost synergy targets". Lower integration legal bills helped cut company-wide professional fees by 54%, saving 2.7 percentage points of net operating revenue.
What to watch: the exact annualised cost-savings figure on the conference call, set against management's $45–46 million year-end target and $50 million first-quarter goal. Hitting $50 million would confirm the full expense benefit will flow into fiscal 2027 profit.
🐻 Bear Case
Bond Portfolio Marks Cut Client Float Income
A core part of the bull case is that StoneX earns interest on its $15.5 billion of total client float, which combines $14.3 billion of listed-derivatives client equity and $1.25 billion of bank-sweep deposits. Even though average listed-derivatives client equity grew 26% from a year ago, net interest and fee revenue on client balances fell 16% to $96.4 million.
The company blamed the drop on a $17.9 million "unrealized marked-to-market loss on U.S. Treasury and Agency positions in our investment portfolio", compared with a $9.0 million unrealized gain a year earlier. In addition, average listed-derivatives client equity slipped 4.7% from the third quarter's $15.0 billion peak as calmer markets required clients to post less cash margin.
- Reported annualised net yield on total float: 2.48% by our math, down from 2.77% in Q3
- Clean net interest on client balances (excluding bond marks): $114.3 million, up 8% from a year ago by our math
- Clean annualised net yield on total float: 2.94% by our math
- RJO gross interest and fee contribution: $48.8 million for three months, down from $50.0 million in two months a year ago
This matters because management invests client cash in Treasury and agency bonds to lock in yields against interest-rate cuts. Those bond holdings introduce quarter-to-quarter valuation swings that cut right through reported earnings, and RJO's lower-yielding balances dilute the overall return.
What to watch: quarterly net interest on client balances in the first quarter as RJO fully laps the comparison. A reading below $100 million without bond losses would show that lower interest rates are eroding the float's earning power faster than balances are growing.
Tighter Spreads Hit Institutional and Retail Profits
StoneX's Institutional division serves fund managers and banks in securities and futures, while Self-Directed/Retail serves individual currency and contract-for-difference (CFD) traders. Both divisions stumbled this quarter as market price swings calmed down and trading spreads tightened.
In Institutional, clients traded 17% more securities per day, but the rate per million dollars traded (RPM) — the revenue StoneX keeps on every million dollars of volume after bond-financing interest — fell 23% to $196. StoneX cited a "narrowing of spreads across both equity and fixed income products", while higher repo borrowing costs pushed Institutional interest expense up 26% to $494.9 million. In Self-Directed/Retail, daily FX and CFD volume fell 17%, pushing the division to a $9.2 million loss after allocated overhead.
- Institutional net operating revenue: $250.7 million, down 13% from a year ago
- Institutional segment profit: $98.9 million, down 25% from a year ago
- Prime services net operating revenue (services for hedge funds): $24.7 million, down 27% from a year ago
- Self-Directed/Retail profit before overhead: $6.4 million, down 56% from a year ago
Why it matters: Institutional is StoneX's largest division by total operating revenue, and its fixed staff costs rose 33% from a year ago. When spreads tighten and float interest drops at the same time, higher volume cannot prevent a profit drop.
What to watch: Securities RPM and Self-Directed/Retail profit after overhead in the first quarter. Another retail loss after overhead would pressure management to restructure or shrink the consumer trading unit.
Volume Growth Came With Lower Fee Rates
Across its automated platforms, StoneX is winning more trading flow from clients by accepting lower fees per trade. That trade-off is still lifting revenue today, but the fee compression deepened in the fourth quarter.
- Payments: average daily volume up 28% to $101 million, but rate per million down 9% to $9,294
- OTC derivatives: contract volumes up 97%, but average rate per contract (RPC, the fee earned on each contract) down 6% to $56.88
- Institutional listed derivatives: contract volumes up 59%, but average RPC down 18% to $1.37
Why it matters: lower pricing works while automated platforms bring in nearly twice as many contracts. Once volume growth slows against tougher comparisons next year, lower fee rates will weigh directly on net operating revenue.
What to watch: Payments RPM and OTC average RPC on the first-quarter release, when the chief executive plans to hold a strategic review of the Payments division. Stabilising fee rates would show the drop was just mix from larger clients rather than price cuts.
👓 Other Themes
Higher Taxes and More Shares Cut Per-Share Profit
StoneX grew pre-tax profit by 10% from a year ago to $119.6 million, even as variable staff bonuses rose by 1.5 percentage points of net operating revenue and fixed pay rose by 0.8 points. However, income tax expense jumped 51% to $35.4 million, lifting the effective tax rate from 21.5% to 29.6% (1.4 points of net operating revenue), while stock issued for acquisitions pushed diluted shares up 5.4% and cut earnings per share by 6% to $0.66.
StoneX Reshuffled Segments and Split Out Prime Services
Management made two reporting changes retroactive to October 2023. It moved the Interest Rates and FX business (formerly FX Prime Brokerage) out of Institutional and into Commercial, and it broke out Prime Services — clearing and financing for hedge funds, which brought in $72.1 million of operating revenue, down 6% — as a separate line from Securities. Separating Prime Services lowered the reported Securities rate per million across all periods.
💲 Other KPIs
Inventory of physical metals and commodities jumped 71.1% from a year ago and 34.7% from the third quarter. Carrying larger physical inventories supports the thriving Commercial supply and precious metals trading desk, though it also raised short-term subsidiary financing interest by 71% to $19.7 million.
Cash owed to brokerage customers on the balance sheet rose 12.2% from a year ago and 5.4% from the third quarter's $21,161.0 million. Even though average daily listed-derivatives equity dipped slightly during the quarter, period-end customer balances finished the fiscal year at a record high.
Book value per share, adjusted for the two three-for-two stock splits completed in March and July 2026, rose 19.7% from $20.25 a year ago and 2.3% from $23.70 in the third quarter. Full-year return on stated equity reached 19.5%, though fourth-quarter return on equity slowed to 11.6%.
❓ Key Questions
What was the exact RJO cost-synergy dollar run-rate at year-end?
Chief executive Philip Smith stated that StoneX achieved its cost synergy targets on schedule, but the release did not print the dollar figure. Investors need to know if annualised savings hit the $45–46 million fourth-quarter target and remain on track for $50 million in the first quarter.
Why did U.S. Treasury and Agency positions book a $17.9M loss?
The company uses fixed-rate swaps and Treasury securities to protect client float income against falling interest rates. A $17.9 million unrealized mark-to-market loss in one quarter cut 16% off net float revenue, raising questions about the maturity profile and accounting treatment of the portfolio.
Where are the six-month savings numbers from the AI rollout?
Last quarter, management promised a six-month update on the fourth-quarter call detailing cost savings and vendor reductions from its company-wide artificial intelligence rollout. With non-trading technology support expenses up 30% from a year ago to $33.2 million, investors will look for quantified savings on the call.
What is the plan to stop losses in Self-Directed/Retail?
After subtracting $15.6 million of allocated overhead, Self-Directed/Retail lost $9.2 million in the fourth quarter, and its full-year profit after overhead dropped 77% to $18.2 million. Management has not yet stated whether it will cut costs or reshape the unit as retail currency volume shrinks.
