Montauk Renewables (MNTK) Q3 2026 earnings review
Montauk's gas output rose, but it may default on loans
Montauk Renewables, which turns waste gas into fuel and power, made more gas but is short of cash. Sales from its own plants rose about 5%, helped by better prices for the federal fuel credits it sells. But Montauk now expects to break its loan terms at year-end unless its lender eases them. Its new pig-manure power plant still runs at low output and needs a $15 million fix.
| Revenue from Montauk's own plants | $46.2M +4.7% from a year ago; total revenue +10.9% |
|---|---|
| Operating profit before depreciation, excluding one-offs | $10.2M โ20.6% from a year ago |
| Cash at the end of September | $12.4M the loan requires at least $10M |
| Full-year sales outlook | Cut middle of the range: $195.5M, from $207M last quarter |
โ๏ธ Verdict: ๐ด Bearish
The story got worse, because Montauk's survival now rests on a new deal with its lender. The full-year sales outlook came down, leaving about 3% growth for the fourth quarter by our math. Three planned gas plants slipped to 2029. One bright spot: each credit fetched a higher price.
The question now is whether the lender signs the amended loan before year-end. A signature lets Montauk borrow more and fix the plant; without one, it expects to default. The signed amendment, or its absence in the fourth-quarter report, will settle it.
๐ Bull Case
Montauk Sold More Credits at Higher Prices
Montauk earns most of its revenue from RINs (Renewable Identification Numbers), federal credits that fuel blenders must buy. It receives them when its gas becomes vehicle fuel. Fewer credits now go out under fixed-price deals, after the "expiration of fixed price pathway contracts".
- Credits sold: 13.9 million, up 12.2% from a year ago
- Average price per credit: $2.58, against $2.29
- Gas sold under fixed-price deals: down 73.9%
This matters because each credit is worth far more than the gas behind it. So revenue at the renewable natural gas division rose 5.2%, even though sales of the gas itself fell by half.
What to watch: the average credit price in the fourth-quarter report. Montauk lowered its gas revenue outlook because of credit prices, so a weaker price would mean the third quarter marked the peak.
Gas Output Rose 6.7% as Landfill Wells Improved
Montauk's renewable natural gas comes from methane that it collects at landfills and cleans to pipeline quality. Output rose 6.7% from a year ago, the best gain this year. Montauk credited "landfill host wellfield operational and collection system enhancements" at its McCarty site.
- McCarty: 60,000 more MMBtu, a standard unit of energy
- Rumpke: 42,000 more, after it widened its gas collection system
- Apex: 26,000 more, from better landfill gas collection
- Pico: 30,000 fewer, during digester maintenance
This matters because landfill owners, not Montauk, run the gas wells at most of its sites. The renewable gas producer still expects delays from those owners, writing: "We expect these trends to continue." So part of this gain came from work it does not control.
What to watch: fourth-quarter gas output against the unchanged full-year plan. Meeting it would show that the wellfield work adds gas every quarter rather than once.
Fuel Venture Earned $2.6 Million for Montauk
GreenWave is a venture Montauk co-owns with a fuel marketer. It lets other gas producers sell fuel through "exclusive unique and proprietary pathways", and Montauk takes its share of the venture's earnings as credits.
- Venture income: $2.6 million, against $3.8 million last quarter
- Revenue from venture credits: $4.0 million, against $8.4 million last quarter
- Pre-tax result without the venture: a $2.0 million loss, by our math
This matters because the venture income exceeded Montauk's net profit of $2.1 million. Its credit revenue and their cost nearly cancel, so its value shows only in that income line. The filing gives no reason for the drop from the second quarter.
What to watch: venture income in the fourth quarter. A further decline would show that the second quarter was the high point rather than the base.
Positives this quarter didn't test
Two supports for Montauk's credit prices come from federal rules and from the refiners that must buy credits. This quarter gave each only a partial reading, so neither moved.
- Federal demand for waste-gas credits: the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) kept its 2026 and 2027 targets, but exempted more small refineries for 2025 in August. Its October proposal to shift those volumes to other refiners would move this.
- Early buying by refiners: Montauk again sold 99% of the credits it had available. The fourth-quarter sales rate will show whether buyers still come early in the year.
๐ป Bear Case
Montauk Needs Its Lender to Avoid a Default
Montauk's release stressed that its accounts carry no formal doubt about its survival. It had expected to include "the previously anticipated going concern qualification". Its filing reads harder: without a new loan deal, Montauk wrote, "we believe it is probable we will not have sufficient liquidity to fund our operations".
The company has signed a non-binding term sheet that would let it borrow more and pause some loan tests for a year. Without that relief, the release says, "we expect to be in default of the covenants thereunder as of December 31, 2026".
- Cash: $12.4 million, against a $10 million minimum in the loan
- Debt: $155 million at 10.25% interest
- Bills due within a year above short-term assets: $23.8 million
- Cash as a share of debt: 10%, down from 19% in March
By our math, only about $2.4 million separates cash from the loan's floor. A non-binding term sheet commits the lender to nothing. So Montauk plans to "temporarily limit development and discretionary capital expenditures" and is discussing new money from shareholders with its board.
What to watch: a signed loan amendment before the December covenant test. Only a signature turns the plan in the filing into actual funding for the next twelve months.
Pig-Waste Power Plant Still Runs at Low Output
Montauk Ag Renewables runs a plant in Turkey, North Carolina, that turns pig manure into electricity and state renewable energy credits, called RECs. It began selling power in July. Through the quarter it produced power, credits and by-products only "at nominal levels", Montauk said.
Engineers found two faults: "the moisture control of our inlet feedstock" and heat loss in the gas between reactors and generators. Fixing both will cost about $15 million and take three months. Work starts only once the lender signs the loan amendment.
- Electricity division operating loss: $3.0 million, against $0.2 million a year ago
- Plant costs charged straight to profit: $1.9 million
- Electricity division revenue: $4.27 million, almost unchanged
This matters because the $200 million plant holds the growth case. Montauk now aims to "begin transferring RECs in 2027", not this year. Meanwhile North Carolina utilities asked regulators in October to delay their swine credit duties. The filing warns this "could impact our ability to successfully execute swine contracts".
What to watch: the first signed swine credit contract with a disclosed price, because the plant earns its return mainly from those credits rather than from power.
Plant Running Costs Rose Faster Than Sales
Operating and maintenance costs, the money Montauk spends to run its plants, rose to 52% of revenue from 39% a year ago. Part of the jump is venture credit cost that offsets matching revenue. Excluding it, by our math, running costs still climbed to 48% of plant revenue from 38%.
- Operating result: a $1.0 million loss, against a $4.4 million profit
- Operating profit before depreciation (EBITDA), excluding one-offs: down 20.6%
- Gas plant cost per unit of gas: $15.98, up 5.4%
Montauk blamed "increased media changes" at its Apex, Rumpke and McCarty gas plants. Overhead also grew 16.4%, because of the "timing of incentive compensation accrual adjustments". So the better credit prices never reached profit.
What to watch: the gas plants' cost per unit of gas next quarter. It will show whether this quarter's heavy maintenance repeats or fades.
Risks this quarter didn't answer
Four standing risks got no decisive reading this quarter. Each still bears on Montauk's profit or its loan, so each item below names the number that would move it.
- Credit price in the loan: the lender can call a default if the monthly credit price drops under $1 while average quarterly EBITDA sits under $10 million. By our math, reported EBITDA averaged $9.7 million over four quarters. The loan defines EBITDA differently, and the credit price stayed far above the trigger.
- Landfill owners and gas supply: McCarty gained gas, but Montauk still expects delays from landfill owners. Fourth-quarter output at McCarty and Apex will show which way this goes.
- One large buyer: an unnamed customer took 29.6% of revenue, up from 25.6% a year ago. A named buyer or its contract length would move this.
- Court cases on federal credit targets: challenges to the 2026 and 2027 targets remain open in a federal appeals court. A ruling would move this.
๐ Other Themes
Montauk Delays Three Gas Projects to 2029
To save cash, Montauk is putting off $100 million to $120 million of planned building work. Its Bowerman, Tulsa and Rumpke gas plants now target 2029, later than before. This year's building budget drops to $65โ75 million. Montauk also warned that it may owe penalties to contractors for the delays.
๐ฒ Other KPIs
Capital spending fell to 39% of revenue, from 66% a year ago. It peaked at 96% at the end of 2025, while building work on the pig-waste plant ran at full pace. Montauk also trimmed this year's upkeep budget to $18โ20 million, which saves cash but slows gas output gains.
Unpaid supplier bills more than doubled since December, from $15.6 million. Higher payables and accruals added $16.9 million to cash from operations over nine months. Montauk now plans to negotiate payment terms with some vendors, so this source of cash may not last.
The share count barely moved, up 0.3% from a year ago. Montauk bought back no shares and paid no dividend. Its board is discussing new shareholder financing for the pig-waste plant, which could add shares if it comes as equity.
๐ฎ Guidance
Cut. Montauk lowered the top of the range by $10 million, citing a "reduction from Environmental Attributes pricing", meaning credit prices. By our math, the fourth quarter then gets about $39.8 million, 13% below the third. It is the first change after three quarters at the same range.
Unchanged. The plan still calls for 5.8 to 6.0 million units of gas this year. By our math, the fourth quarter needs about 1.55 million. That is roughly 11% above a year earlier. The producer set the same range for 2025 and delivered 5.6 million.
Cut again. The electricity forecast now tops out at $19 million. This is the third cut in three quarters. The middle of the range has fallen from $38 million in March to $18 million. By our math, the fourth quarter gets about $5.1 million, little above the old plants' pace. Montauk tied the cut to its pig-waste plant.
Cut. Montauk now expects 170,000 to 175,000 megawatt-hours of power this year. By our math, that leaves about 44,500 for the fourth quarter. That is slightly below a year earlier. In March the outlook reached as high as 207,000, because it counted on the pig-waste plant.
โ Key Questions
Will the lender sign the loan amendment before December?
Montauk expects to break its loan terms at year-end without relief. The term sheet is non-binding, so its signing date and terms decide whether the plant fix and further borrowing can start.
What price does Duke Energy pay per swine credit?
Duke Energy agreed to buy 47,000 of the plant's yearly credits. Montauk believes each could fetch $200 to $400. No signed price is public, so readers cannot test that belief.
Why did venture income fall from the second quarter?
GreenWave income dropped to $2.6 million from $3.8 million, and the filing gives no reason. The venture now supplies more than Montauk's whole net profit, so its pace matters.
When will the pig-waste plant reach full output?
Montauk has repeated targets of 120,000 credits and 41,000 megawatt-hours a year without a date. The start slipped from April to July, so a timetable would show how far away full output is.
Who is the customer behind 30% of revenue?
One unnamed buyer took 29.6% of third-quarter revenue. Its name and contract length would show how exposed Montauk is if that buyer leaves.
