Bullish (BLSH) Q3 2026 earnings review
Bullish cuts operating costs, but its service revenue slows down
Bullish, an institutional cryptocurrency exchange and owner of CoinDesk, cut operating costs to lift profit while its revenue growth slowed. Revenue excluding one-offs rose 10% from a year ago to $84 million, and finance chief David Bonanno lifted the operating cash profit margin to 42%. However, management trimmed the top of its full-year service revenue plan, which by our math leaves growth slowing to 3% in the fourth quarter.
| Revenue, excluding one-offs | $84.4M +10% from a year ago, -9% from Q2 |
|---|---|
| Operating profit (Adjusted EBITDA) | $35.6M +24% from a year ago (42% margin) |
| Full-year service revenue outlook | Cut $5M middle of the range: $230M |
| Full-year finance expense outlook | Raised $6.5M middle of the range: $62.5M |
⚖️ Verdict: 🔴 Bearish
The story got worse because the service revenue line that was supposed to offset quiet crypto trading is plateauing while interest costs rise. Trimming the full-year service revenue range and lifting the finance expense plan by $6.5 million outweigh a one-quarter drop in overhead costs. On the positive side, chief executive Tom Farley kept the Equiniti buyout on track for January 2027 and brought the New York Stock Exchange into its tokenized-stock group.
The question now is whether subscription and service revenue can grow on its own when crypto prices stay quiet. Either new partner mandates will lift fourth-quarter revenue above the plan, or lower token prices will hold the line flat near $56 million. Fourth-quarter service revenue and the January 2027 Equiniti closing will settle it.
🐂 Bull Case
Lower Operating Costs Lifted the Profit Margin
Bullish runs a digital-asset exchange and owns CoinDesk, a crypto data and media business. After two quarters of falling operating profit, finance chief David Bonanno pointed to tighter spending. "Our diversified model and cost discipline delivered year-over-year revenue and earnings growth in a challenging market," Bonanno said. Operating profit before interest, taxes and depreciation, excluding one-offs (Adjusted EBITDA), rose 24.5% from a year ago to $35.6 million.
By our math from the nine-month tables, operating expenses excluding one-offs dropped to $48.7 million from $63.1 million in the second quarter, when Bullish paid for its flagship Miami conference. That reduced core overhead from 68.1% of adjusted revenue to 57.7%, lifting the Adjusted EBITDA margin to 42.2%. Management also lowered its full-year operating expense plan by $5 million at the middle of the range.
What to watch: fourth-quarter operating expenses excluding one-offs, which the updated full-year outlook puts at $53.0 million by our math. Holding costs near that mark will confirm that the leaner expense base is permanent rather than a one-quarter dip.
Tokenization Coalition Adds Big Market Partners
Chief executive Tom Farley is reshaping the group around tokenized shares, which are traditional company stocks recorded on a blockchain. "I believe the move from electronic to tokenized shares is as inevitable as the move from paper to electronic, and for the same reasons: it is faster, more efficient, and far cheaper," Farley said. The centrepiece is the pending $4.2 billion buyout of Equiniti, a share-registration business.
This quarter Bullish hired former New York Stock Exchange president Stacey Cunningham as its president for "connecting traditional capital markets infrastructure with blockchain technology". It also launched the Issuer Token Coalition with Equiniti to "advance the standards and infrastructure for issuer-sponsored tokenized securities", signing up the New York Stock Exchange, SoFi, DRW and Flow Traders. Management still expects the Equiniti purchase to close in January 2027.
What to watch: regulatory sign-off and the January 2027 closing of the Equiniti deal, where Bullish plans to "work directly with thousands of issuers to bring equities into the digital age". Any delay would stall the company's primary growth plan.
Positives this quarter didn't test
Two standing growth drivers from earlier quarters received no new figures in the third-quarter earnings release and financial tables.
- Institutional client wins on the regulated exchange: management did not update onboarding numbers or trading volumes from recent wealth-manager partnerships; the earnings call or presentation will show whether institutional market share grew.
- CoinDesk media traffic and index mandates: the release omits website pageviews and total assets tracking CoinDesk benchmarks after Morgan Stanley's second-quarter product launches; the supplemental slide deck will show if index assets grew.
🐻 Bear Case
The Recurring Revenue Engine Is Slowing Down
Bullish pitches its subscription, services and other revenue — covering CoinDesk indices, events, lending interest and liquidity fees — as a steady counterweight to volatile trading fees. Bonanno highlighted that this line rose 13.3% from a year ago to $56.4 million by our math. That landed near the top of the $48.4 million to $57.4 million range implied by the company's prior second-half split.
Beating the middle of that implied range did not lead to a higher target. Instead, Bullish cut the top of its full-year outlook by $10 million, lowering the range to $225 million to $235 million. By our math, the new middle of the range leaves $56.2 million for the fourth quarter, or 2.9% growth from a year ago, down from 96.6% growth in the second quarter.
- Third-quarter service revenue: $56.4 million by our math, down 10.0% from the second quarter
- Nine-month service revenue: $173.8 million, up 70.2% from a year ago
- Implied fourth-quarter service revenue: $51.2 million to $61.2 million by our math, or 2.9% growth at the middle of the range
What to watch: fourth-quarter subscription, services and other revenue against the implied $56.2 million mark. A drop toward the $51.2 million floor would show that softer crypto prices are dragging down index and liquidity fees.
Rising Interest Costs Eat Into Operating Profit
Bullish carries $484.2 million in non-current borrowings from related parties on its balance sheet, down slightly from $505.6 million at the end of 2025. Servicing that debt takes a large share of what the exchange and data businesses earn. In the third quarter, finance expense rose 16.0% from a year ago to $16.1 million, while cash interest paid rose 59.9% to $15.9 million.
While management lowered its full-year targets for both service revenue and operating expenses, it raised its full-year finance expense outlook from $52 million–$60 million to $60 million–$65 million. Finance costs absorbed 45.3% of Adjusted EBITDA this quarter, and operating cash flow was negative $8.1 million. That interest burden is climbing before Bullish assumes roughly $1.85 billion of additional debt to close the Equiniti buyout.
What to watch: fourth-quarter finance expense, which the raised outlook puts at $17.8 million at the middle of the range by our math. Higher borrowing costs ahead of the Equiniti closing will leave less cash flow from standalone operations.
Crypto Cycle Drives Wide Accounting Swings
Soft cryptocurrency trading activity continues to weigh on the exchange. Gross digital-asset sales reported under International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) fell 22.9% from a year ago to $32.1 billion. Total revenue excluding one-offs rose 10.3% from a year ago to $84.4 million, but dropped 8.9% from the second quarter after staying near $92.6 million for three straight quarters.
Meanwhile, token price swings create wide gaps between reported accounting profit and operating profit. Reported net income reached $576.3 million this quarter because of a $598.4 million upward fair-value mark on digital assets held, compared with $18.7 million in net income excluding one-offs. Across the first nine months of 2026, however, digital-asset markdowns pushed Bullish to a reported net loss of $308.6 million.
What to watch: fourth-quarter gross digital-asset sales and transaction revenue. Another drop from the $32.1 billion quarterly pace would show that institutional trading volumes have not yet recovered.
Risks this quarter didn't answer
Four standing risks lacked updated figures in the third-quarter release and financial statements.
- Service revenue breakdown: the release does not split out non-customer income or liquidity fees inside the $56.4 million service total; footnote disclosures will show how much relies on non-customer items.
- Customer concentration and spot volumes: major-customer sales tables and spot or options trading volumes were omitted; the full quarterly notes will show whether four clients still drive two-thirds of volume.
- US derivatives and tokenization rules: management gave no update on its US futures partner or federal token exemptions; regulatory filings will show when US derivatives trading can start.
- Equiniti standalone performance: no financial figures were published for Equiniti ahead of the January 2027 close; post-close pro forma tables will provide the first check on its 2026 targets.
👓 Other Themes
New $300 Million Share Buyback Plan
Bullish's board approved a share buyback programme of up to $300 million, its first since going public in August 2025. The authorisation does not require the group to buy a set number of shares, and Bullish executed no buybacks in the third quarter. The plan arrives just before Bullish issues $2.35 billion in new stock to pay for the Equiniti acquisition in January 2027.
💲 Other KPIs
Transaction revenue — the fees and trading spreads earned from customers on the Bullish Exchange — rose 4.9% from a year ago to $28.0 million. However, it fell 6.4% from $29.9 million in the second quarter and is down from $38.0 million in the first quarter as quieter crypto markets curbed trading.
Net liquid assets — the digital assets, cash and financial investments owned by the group after subtracting customer funds and debt — stood at $2.70 billion on September 30. That is down 5.7% from $2.86 billion at the end of 2025, but recovered by $595.8 million from the second quarter as crypto prices rose.
Weighted average diluted shares rose 11.2% from a year ago to 155.9 million, reflecting the August 2025 initial public offering and employee stock awards. In addition, the digital-asset platform issued $29.0 million of warrants over the first nine months under its Trading Rewards Program to attract exchange volume.
🔮 Guidance
Cut. Management trimmed the top end of the full-year range by $10 million, lowering the middle of the range by $5 million to $230 million (45.8% growth for the year). By our math, subtracting nine-month revenue of $173.8 million leaves $56.2 million for the fourth quarter, slowing growth to 2.9% from a year ago. Bullish had held the $235 million midpoint across its three prior updates.
Cut. The crypto group lowered its full-year expense plan by $5 million at the middle of the range to $222.5 million, or 14.6% higher than 2025. By our math, that leaves $53.0 million for the fourth quarter, up from $48.7 million in the third quarter and 10.3% above last year's fourth quarter. It reverses a $7.5 million midpoint increase made in the second quarter.
Raised. The company lifted its full-year interest cost outlook by $6.5 million at the middle of the range to $62.5 million, after holding it at $52 million–$60 million for three straight quarters. By our math, nine-month finance costs of $44.7 million leave $17.8 million for the fourth quarter, up from $16.1 million this quarter and 19.3% higher than a year ago.
❓ Key Questions
Why cut the service revenue ceiling after a third-quarter beat?
Third-quarter subscription and services revenue of $56.4 million landed near the top of the range implied by last quarter's split. Cutting the full-year ceiling by $10 million points to fourth-quarter softness in index fees, lending interest or liquidity services.
Why did full-year finance expense jump by $6.5 million?
Related-party debt on the balance sheet fell from $505.6 million at year-end to $484.2 million, yet management raised the full-year finance expense plan to $60 million–$65 million. Investors need to know if borrowing rates reset higher or if Equiniti bridge financing costs started.
How much of third-quarter service revenue came from non-customers?
In the second quarter, $13.0 million of non-customer income and $4.7 million of interest income sat inside the subscription and services line. The third-quarter release did not disclose those figures, leaving underlying customer demand unclear.
What were exchange trading volumes and top-customer shares in Q3?
Four customers accounted for roughly 68% of exchange sales in the second quarter, when spot and options volume totalled $131 billion. The third-quarter release did not include volume or customer concentration tables.
